MOORLACH UPDATE — Boondoggle — December 10, 2014

My News LA, in the first piece below, provides an update on the ambulance RFP un-termination (see MOORLACH UPDATE — Ambulance RFP Termination — November 4, 2014). Because there were several legal concerns that I did not believe should be shared in open session, I decided to abstain on the proposed solution. I can’t remember my last abstention, but felt that the motion was close to what I was comfortable with, but not precisely.

In the second piece, the LA Times asked my thoughts on the new ARTIC station in Anaheim. You can see from my previous posts, see MOORLACH UPDATE — ARTIC — February 15, 2011 and MOORLACH UPDATE — ARTIC — January 14, 2011, that I stayed consistent with my position.

O.C. supervisors restart hiring process for ambulance service providers

Posted by John Schreiber

Orange County supervisors on Tuesday approved a do-over on the process of hiring ambulance service providers, overturning a decision by the Health Care Agency director to junk a batch of requests for proposals.

County attorneys warned officials that starting the process all over again would present legal issues, so the supervisors opted instead to recruit a new panel of experts to pick ambulance companies from a batch of RFPs instead of seeking new bids.

Orange County Supervisor Todd Spitzer said it wouldn’t be fair to let the ambulance companies submit new bids because they would be able to look at what their competitors submitted in the first round of RFPs and adjust their new proposals accordingly.

County officials had recommended “starting from scratch,” but Spitzer led the effort to keep the original RFPs, which are under protest by some ambulance providers because the process was considered tainted.

“I think there was a panelist trying to skew the outcome” on which companies would be hired for emergency transport to hospitals, Spitzer told City News Service. “I think there was a plant, if you will, among the panelists. The scoring presented such an outlier statistically that it couldn’t withstand scrutiny.”

Health Care Agency Director Mark Refowitz recently tossed all of the bids, but the board voted 3-0, with Supervisor John Moorlach abstaining, to rescind that order.

Supervisor Lisa Bartlett suggested eliminating any of the original members of a panel evaluating and scoring the RFP in favor of a new set of experts to review the bids. Bartlett also recommended letting the new panel get a chance to ask questions of the bidders about their proposals.

Bartlett also convinced her fellow supervisors to go along with putting city representatives on the panel reviewing the bids, which would quell complaints from some quarters that cities weren’t being represented in the hiring of ambulance companies in five zones. The city representatives, however, would not be allowed to vote on contracts for service affecting the towns in which they reside or work.

“This is a way to put it back to square one while protecting the sanctity of the original process,” Spitzer said after today’s board meeting.

City News Service

Gleaming new transportation hub reflects O.C.’s embrace of public transit

Orange County’s new transportation center is designed to unite previously scattered transportation services

A Metrolink commuter train pulls into the Anaheim Regional Transportation Intermodal Center, which opened Dec. 6. (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times)

By Emily FoxhalL

While Los Angeles over the last decade has invested heavily in new rail systems, Orange County has largely kept its eyes on the road — widening freeways, improving traffic flow, building better interchanges.

But this week, commuters got their first view of an enormous, airy transportation hub that reflects Orange County’s growing embrace of public transit.

The $188-million transportation center in the heart of Anaheim, not far from Disneyland, is designed as a central hub where trains, buses, cars and bicycles will converge. Officials hope it ultimately will be the final stop for the state’s proposed high-speed bullet train.

A statement about future

Backers say the aim wasn’t just to create a train station but to also make a statement about the future. They wanted a central station to unite previously scattered transportation services, said Curt Pringle, the former mayor of Anaheim and once board chairman of the California High-Speed Rail Authority.

"It’s planned to be a part of a vibrant community that’s going to grow up around it for a long time," he said.

The 67,000-square-foot station was two decades in the planning, long enough that the ambitious plans for a countywide light-rail system were drawn up and then shelved. But plans for what was to be Orange County’s premier transportation hub never lost momentum.

The Anaheim Regional Transportation Intermodal Center — ARTIC, for short — sits next to the 57 Freeway, adjacent to the Honda Center and Angel Stadium and a short distance from Disney Resort and the Anaheim Convention Center.

Bus stops for Orange County Transportation Authority routes and private carriers surround the station, while Amtrak and Metrolink trains pick up and drop off passengers on two tracks that passengers reach via a sky bridge.

There are 1,082 parking spaces, a wide circular drive that invites car drop-offs and a dozen bicycle lockers plus additional bike racks.

Progress or ‘boondoggle’

Critics, though, can’t help but point out a missing component. Despite the boasting, the hub so far has no bullet train platform — just a space allocated for it.

ARTIC: Anaheim’s transportation hub

The $188-million Anaheim Regional Transportation Intermodal Center (ARTIC) in Anaheim will serve as Orange County’s multi-modal transportation hub.

"It’s a boondoggle," said John Moorlach, a county supervisor and an OCTA board member. "It’s just too much building for too little service."

Although the station is expected to have more than 10,000 daily boardings, the old one-room train depot, tucked in a parking lot beyond center field in Angel Stadium, was only lightly used.

According to OCTA records, the depot had an average of 510 weekday boardings last fiscal year, ranking it seventh among 10 Orange County Metrolink stops. The busiest, Irvine and Fullerton, had three times as many boardings.

The station also ranked third among six Amtrak Pacific Surfliner stops in the county, with 389 average weekday boardings.

All of which causes Supervisor Shawn Nelson, who chairs OCTA’s board of directors, to wonder how the cavernous building will get more people involved in transit.

"There’s a little delusional sort of behavior with this," he said. "They wanted this so bad they refused to look at some of the realities."

A soaring design

The station itself is a stunning crisscross of steel pipes that form a rounded skeleton that seems to hover above the ground like a cloud.

A commuter walks through the 67,000-square-foot Anaheim Regional Transportation Intermodal Center. (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times)

Translucent pillows of Teflon-impregnated plastic — the same material used in Beijing’s National Aquatics Center, or Water Cube, and Fisht Olympic Stadium in Sochi, Russia — fill each diamond of the frame, allowing the sun to light 75% of the public space in the building, which is also powered by solar panels.

More than 600 strips of LED lights will turn the pipes red for Angels games and orange when the Ducks play. The teams will have pre- and post-game shows oriented toward the center.

Inside, a large open area faces a main staircase that soars up the building’s three levels, each one recessed from the next. Hot and cold water piped through the floors controls the temperature on each level.

On the ground floor, ticket counters with information on scrolling digital strips await passengers. A "progressive convenience store" and a kiosk offering organic coffee are planned.

Upstairs, restaurants are scheduled to open next year that will offer passengers opportunity to grab a bowl of quinoa and super veggies, watch oysters be shucked, or sip a hand-crafted cocktail at a bar.

Need directions?

Travelers on Monday evening said they were still taking in the spaceship-like building.

"We’re all confused!" said Judith Smith, 61, a rail commuter for 28 years. "I thought I was going into, maybe, the airport."

Socorro Velasco, 42, who takes the train several times a week from L.A. to her job in Anaheim, said she now has to walk a little farther to get to the depot.

Waiting on a bench outside, she said she thought commuters would like the building once they got used to it. But she wasn’t quite ready to go inside just yet.

"I didn’t want to get lost in there!" she said.


Disclaimer: You have been added to my MOORLACH UPDATE communication e-mail tree. In lieu of a weekly newsletter, you will receive occasional media updates, some with commentary to explain the situation, whenever I appear in the media (unless it is a duplication of a previous story).

I have two thoughts for you to consider: (1) my office does not usually issue press releases to get into the newspapers (only in rare cases); and (2) I do not write the articles, opinions or letters to the editor.

This message should appear at the bottom of every e-mail you receive. If these e-mails should stop arriving in your mail box, it will be because your address has changed and you did not provide a new one. If you do not wish to receive these e-mails, then please e-mail back and request to unsubscribe.